Welcome to Green Hill Diner
Green Hill Diner, nestled in Morgantown, Indiana, is a charming eatery celebrated for its retro ambiance and commitment to locally sourced ingredients. Here, you’re welcomed not just with friendly service, but also with a menu that showcases a delightful twist on classic comfort foods. From their signature Steak Frites to inventive breakfast brioche sandwiches adorned with homemade sauces, each dish reflects quality and creativity. Patrons rave about the exceptional flavor, especially the fries cooked in beef tallow, likening them to gourmet offerings from high-end restaurants. Green Hill Diner truly captures the essence of a hidden gem, making it a must-visit for food lovers.
Green Hill Diner: Reviews & Ratings
This diner was unassuming, but so good! It has a beautiful, retro atmosphere and serves locally sourced foods. Loved it!
We've been here several times since we discovered it a couple months ago - and will continue to come. The staff is really friendly, the food is really good and the atmosphere just chill. Been here for Breakfast, Brunch and Lunch.
The diner is surprisingly delicious and high quality food. The fries are amazing, cooked in beef tallow, they are most similar to what is served at a 5 Guys but even better. The tenderloin was very good, the breading was great and the quality was off that you find at - price restaurants. Would recommend, great place, and a real hidden gem!
This place should be on everyone’s list to visit! This small, hometown diner kills it. The chef adds a lot of less typical sauces or elements to a lot of classic dishes, like feta and sweet n sour on fried green tomatoes or a homemade mayo/mustard on the breakfast brioche sandwich. Everything is always so good! Their brisket tacos posted on their Facebook look amazing! Servers are always great and friendly. Can’t get better than a scratch kitchen with high quality food!
I drove like 2 hours to get to this place with my friends. Place was exceptionally cozy and the service was very polite and on point. The food was EXCELSIOR and was easy one of the best chicken sandwiches I’ve ever had. Milkshake was a good cherry on top after finishing the solid meal. I will be going back to try the Hot Honey Chicken Grilled Cheese. Would recommend this place.
Stopped in because, little diners have good eats. This one here doesn't disappoint. I'm a traveling Welder. So little dives are it. I highly recommend their biscuits and gravy. For all you tenderloin fans they have a top shelf tenderloin. Fries are fresh cut.
I don’t normally order a grilled tenderloin, but our waitress recommended it for the Cuban. It was the best tenderloin sandwich that I have ever had. I think grilled tenderloin can be a little dry and chewy, but this was flat, tender, and juicy. Our waitress told us that they pound, brine, and cold smoke all of their tenderloins. On their menu, they have this sandwich and a more classically topped tenderloin, both available grilled or fried. The Cuban is topped with mayonnaise, mustard, Swiss cheese, and a homemade bacon marmalade, served with a side of fresh-cut fries fried in beef tallow. Beer-battered fried green tomatoes with goat cheese and a chili sauce were also incredible. Service was top notch. Sometimes it can be a little intimidating to go into a small-town diner filled with locals, but their staff made us feel right at home. They were friendly and fast. An all-around amazing experience. Definitely worth our drive. A must-visit for anyone who enjoys great food.
Stopped in 5-7-23. Gizzard were soft ,not like the chewy kind. I liked the batter. We were just stopping to get a snack because we heard it was the best place in Morgantown. Staff was great. Owner super nice. Clean and plenty of parking. Definitely Unique wall decorations. Comfortable seating. Unique menu items and I look forward to coming back to try them all, especially that tenderloin!
Location
-
679 IN-135, Morgantown, IN 46160, United States Hotline: +1 317-800-5625
Welcome to Green Hill Diner, a delightful gem tucked away at 679 IN-135, Morgantown, IN 46160. This unassuming diner has swiftly gained a reputation for high-quality, locally sourced fare, exceptional service, and a warm, retro ambiance that invites you to linger a little longer.
Step inside, and you'll find an atmosphere steeped in nostalgia, yet brimming with life. From the cheerful decor to the inviting smells wafting from the kitchen, Green Hill Diner strikes the perfect balance between comfort and culinary creativity.
Breakfast here is a standout experience, with offerings that include Three Eggs at just $5.09 and Side Ham for $5.00. If you’re craving a sweet start to your day, don’t miss their Side French Toast for $6.00 or indulgent Pancakes at the same price. Pair these with a side of Hashbrowns for $5.00 to elevate your morning routine.
Gourmet Twists on Classic Dishes
Green Hill Diner isn't just about hearty portions; it's about innovative flair. Many guests rave about unique touches—like feta and sweet sour sauces drizzled over fried green tomatoes or the chef’s signature homemade mayo on the breakfast brioche sandwich. This creative approach sets the diner apart and delights the palate.
Lunch and Dinner That Dazzle
The menu doesn’t stop at breakfast. Patrons have sung praises for dishes like their brisket tacos, which not only look delicious but also promise an explosion of flavors. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a leisurely dinner, the food here is remarkably satisfying. It's no wonder customers like Kevin Miller keep returning for the casual vibe and friendly service.
Raving Reviews
- Alexandra LaMar notes the diner’s "beautiful, retro atmosphere" and emphasizes its unpretentious yet delicious offering of local foods.
- David Smith describes the fries as "amazing," likening them to those at 5 Guys but “even better.”
- Deacon Rottler recounts a memorable meal driven two hours just to indulge in a fantastic chicken sandwich, followed by a creamy milkshake.
It’s clear that Green Hill Diner has carved out a special niche in Morgantown, where every meal feels like a home-cooked adventure. The combination of friendly service, indulgent flavors, and heartfelt dedication creates a dining experience that is as comforting as it is delicious. Make sure to put Green Hill Diner on your food itinerary—you won’t regret it!